Skip to main content

Table 3 Changes in Pulmonary function, respiratory muscle strength, fatigue, physical activity, HrQoL within and between the groups

From: The effectiveness of functional inspiratory muscle training on exercise capacity and peripheral muscle strength in patients with essential hypertension: a three-arm randomized controlled trial

 

CG (n: 15)

IMT (n: 15)

F-IMT (n: 15)

 
 

Baseline mean ± SD

After mean ± SD

Mean Difference (95% CI

Within group p

Baseline mean ± SD

After mean ± SD

Mean Difference (95% CI

Within group p

Baseline mean ± SD

After mean ± SD

Mean Difference (95% CI

Within group p

Treatment effect p

FEV1/FVC %

86.24 ± 9.47

86.35 ± 9.11

−0.18(−1.29-.0.92)

0.734

85.18 ± 8.57

85.91 ± 7.38

−0.74(−1.85–0.36)

0.181

82.85 ± 14.21

84.03 ± 14.29

−1.08(−2.19–0.29)

0.056

0.517

MIP cmH2O

93.26 ± 24.77

96.86 ± 25.39

−3.99(−12.50–4.52)

0.350

89.26 ± 25.88

104.58 ± 28.30

−10.33(−18.82–1.84)

0.018

87.26 ± 24.65

100.37 ± 26.95

−17.01(−25.51–8.50)

 < 0.001

0.106

MIP %

100.39 ± 26.06

103.96 ± 25.17

−3.71(−13.27–5.85)

0.438

96.04 ± 23.86

107.73 ± 26.97

−11.60(−21.15–2.05)

0.018

96.64 ± 28.13

117.53 ± 38.14

−20.83 (−30.38–11.28)

 < 0.001

0.048a

MEP cmH2O

104.60 ± 25.35

105.00 ± 24.54

−1.26(−8.49–5.97)

0.817

96.93 ± 34.33

99.01 ± 35.63

−2.22(−9.34–4.89)

0.532

81.60 ± 32.77

94.80 ± 28.44

−12.19(−19.46–4.91)

0.002

0.075

MEP %

88.26 ± 21.47

88.28 ± 18.92

−0.75(−7.73–6.23)

0.829

81.27 ± 24.87

84.16 ± 28.75

−2.86(−9.78–4.05)

0.408

75.11 ± 38.35

87.10 ± 36.73

−11.27(−18.25–4.29)

0.002

0.090

SF-36 Mental Health

70.05 ± 23.26

79.48 ± 19.91

−9.77(−14.35–5.19)

 < 0.001

66.35 ± 20.71

76.40 ± 19.08

−9.73(−14.16–5.31)

 < 0.001

68.05 ± 17.00

75.17 ± 17.25

−7.10(−11.52–2.68)

0.002

0.620

SF-36 Physical Health

70.04 ± 17.87

71.23 ± 17.88

−1.65(−6.65–3.34)

0.508

63.79 ± 21.00

66.67 ± 21.71

−2.70(−2.08–7.49)

0.260

63.13 ± 15.14

65.94 ± 15.76

−2.56(−7.35–2.23)

0.286

0.054

FSS (0–63)

24.66 ± 19.97

23.27 ± 15.83

2.13(−0.64–4.90)

0.128

39.06 ± 18.24

36.17 ± 17.63

1.88(−0.94–4.71)

0.186

28.46 ± 12.79

22.53 ± 11.09

6.21(3.49–8.92)

 < 0.001

0.049a,b

IPAQ total (MET- min/week)

1604.90 ± 1878.56

1741.24 ± 1844.97

−146.51(257.09–35.93)

0.011

394.66 ± 334.13

683.97 ± 539.74

280.02(−419.18–140.86)

 < 0.001

665.42 ± 553.45

1030.83 ± 549.40

−360.48(−470.40–250.55)

 < 0.001

0.035

IPAQ vigorous (MET-min/week)

304.00 ± 693.61

432.00 ± 1264

1.83(−160.98–164.65)

0.982

0.00 ± 0.00

0.00 ± 00

−75.73(−234.55–83.07)

0.341

32.00 ± 123.39

64.00 ± 247.87

−86.09(−243.88–71.68)

0.277

0.688

IPAQ moderate (MET- min./week)

270.40 ± 515.01

1393.68 ± 3879.07

−1235.31(−2457.0–13.61)

0.050

84.00 ± 325.33

249.41 ± 381.30

131.34(−1322.68–1059.99)

0.825

28.00 ± 108.44

157.23 ± 177.45

−51.27(−1255.81–1153.26)

0.932

0.323

IPAQ walking (MET- min./week)

875.13 ± 633.74

878.41 ± 682.52

−17.19(−173.66—139.27)

0.825

544.80 ± 563.26

723.14 ± 607.59

−170.60(−324.29–16.91)

0.030

568.66 ± 422.89

823.16 ± 446.24

−248.32(−401.55–95.08)

0.002

0.116

IPAQ sitting (MET- min./week)

410.0 ± 224.97

385.20 ± 223.18

41.37(−21.07–103.81)

0.188

509.00 ± 384.45

384.05 ± 149.17

84.92(21.89–147.94)

0.010

398.00 ± 184.04

322.58 ± 111.21

98.85(36.29–161.42)

0.03

0.398

  1. FEV1 forced expiratory volume in 1 s, FVC forced vital capacity, MIP maximal inspiratory pressure, MEP maximal expiratory pressure, FSS Fatigue severity scale, SF-36 Short Form, IPAQ International physical activity questionnaire, Bonferroni corrected ANCOVA test
  2. * p < 0.05
  3. astatistically significant difference in comparison with FIMT and CG
  4. bstatistically significant difference in comparison in FIMT and IMT
  5. cstatistically significant difference in comparison in IMT and CG